Red Bull Salzburg’s Struggles: Leadership Vacuums and Organizational Lessons

The recent 5-0 defeat of RB Salzburg to Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League provides more than just a sports headline—it offers critical insights into how leadership vacuums affect performance in sports and beyond.

While Salzburg’s physical training regimen is presumably unchanged, their performance raises questions about the impact of mental fitness, leadership, and organizational identity. These dynamics are relevant not only in football but also in broader business contexts, especially when smaller units operate within large corporate ecosystems.

The Power Vacuum and Mental Fitness

Since 2003 I am engaged in several projects and studies in the field of Mental Wellness and thus I am intrigued by what I have witnessed recently during the battle between Bayer 04 Leverkusen and FC Red Bull Salzburg. Despite no evident decline in physical preparation, RB Salzburg’s recent performances suggest an erosion of mental resilience. This aligns with research showing that leadership uncertainty and organizational instability directly impact mental fitness. Players in team sports thrive on clarity, trust, and a shared sense of purpose—all of which can be undermined by a power vacuum.

When leadership is absent or uncertain, teams struggle to maintain focus, confidence, and unity. Salzburg’s lack of sovereignty on the pitch reflects these struggles, with players appearing disoriented and disconnected.

Key Insight for Management: Organizations must address the mental fitness of their teams during transitions, ensuring that uncertainty at the top does not cascade down and impact performance.

Leadership and Team Identity

Leadership is not just about making decisions; it is about embodying and reinforcing team identity (Eckel & Grossmann, 2005). At RB Salzburg, the apparent lack of clear leadership has scrutinized the team’s collective identity and eroded their sovereignty on the field. Without a strong sense of who they are and what they stand for, teams—and organizations—lose their edge.

This phenomenon is not limited to sports. In business, when leadership falters, team members may lose confidence in their roles, leading to inefficiency, conflict, and declining performance as esteemed Harvard University colleague Amy Edmondson describes in the context of her works on psychological safety.

Lesson for Business: Strong leadership reinforces a team’s identity, ensuring alignment and a shared sense of purpose. Organizations must focus on identity-building as part of their leadership development strategy.

The Decrease in Organizational Identity and Performability

In RB Salzburg’s case, the erosion of organizational identity is clearly linked to declining performance. This is a common issue for smaller units within large organizations, where identity often hinges on the leadership and support provided by the parent company.

Red Bull’s broader leadership vacuum appears to have left RB Salzburg struggling to define their role and identity within the corporate structure. This lack of clarity weakens the team's performability—their ability to execute effectively and consistently in high-pressure situations.

Key Takeaway for Companies: Smaller units in large corporations must have clearly defined identities and roles within the broader organization. Leadership transitions at the corporate level should prioritize communication and alignment to prevent such units from losing their focus.

RB Salzburg as an SME in Red Bull’s Ecosystem

RB Salzburg operates as a small-to-medium enterprise (SME) within the larger corporate structure of Red Bull. This dynamic is similar to smaller divisions within large companies, where the success of the unit depends heavily on the support, resources, and leadership provided by the parent organization.

Implications for Management:

1. Smaller units require a level of autonomy to maintain operational stability during corporate transitions.
2. Clear communication and leadership continuity are critical for preserving the identity and performance of smaller units.
3. Parent companies must recognize the unique needs of their smaller units and provide tailored support to ensure resilience during periods of uncertainty.

How RB Salzburg Can Recover: Insights from Case Studies

1. Borussia Dortmund's Rebuild (2017-2019): After a leadership and performance slump, Borussia Dortmund invested heavily in rebuilding their team identity. This included hiring a clear, charismatic coach and fostering strong relationships between players, management, and fans. Salzburg could adopt a similar approach by appointing a leader with a clear vision and focusing on team-building initiatives.
2. Leicester City’s Resilience Post-Title Win (2016-2018): Following their surprise Premier League title win, Leicester City faced organizational instability and declining performance. Their turnaround was driven by emphasizing core values, ensuring leadership continuity, and nurturing their underdog spirit. Salzburg could leverage their own “outsider” identity to reignite their competitive edge.
3. Red Bull Ice Hockey Division: The ice hockey teams, EHC Red Bull München and EC Red Bull Salzburg, have become a blueprint for stability and success within the Red Bull sports ecosystem. By leveraging decentralized leadership, a strong cultural foundation, and consistent investment in talent development, these teams have achieved sustained excellence, including multiple league titles and international accolades. Their focus on local autonomy, combined with alignment to Red Bull’s overarching vision, showcases how empowering operational units can create a resilient and winning organization, even amidst broader corporate transitions. I shall dive into this topic in my next article as part of the Red Bull series here on Linkedin.

Steps for RB Salzburg to Get Out of the Dilemma

1. Strengthen Leadership: Appoint a strong, clear leader who can unify the team and reinforce their identity. This leader must be able to communicate a compelling vision that aligns with both the team's goals and Red Bull's broader objectives.
2. Reinforce Team Identity: Invest in initiatives that bring players, coaches, and management closer together. This could include team-building exercises, community engagement, and a renewed focus on Salzburg’s unique role within the Red Bull ecosystem.
3. Enhance Communication with Red Bull: Establish clearer lines of communication and support between RB Salzburg and Red Bull’s central leadership. This ensures that Salzburg receives the resources and guidance needed to navigate this transitional period.
4. Focus on Mental Fitness: Implement programs to enhance players’ mental resilience, such as sports psychology sessions, mindfulness training, and workshops on coping with uncertainty.
5. Leverage Existing Infrastructure: Use Salzburg’s robust youth development program to identify and promote emerging talent, creating a sense of continuity and hope for the future.

RB Salzburg’s recent challenges in performance highlight the critical importance of leadership, team identity, communication, mental resilience, and talent development. To address these issues effectively, organizations like Red Bull must focus on these five strategic areas:

1. Strengthen Leadership

Leadership is the cornerstone of team cohesion and performance, particularly during transitional periods. A strong, clear leader can serve as a unifying force, providing direction and stability while reinforcing the team’s identity. This individual must possess a compelling vision that aligns with the immediate goals of RB Salzburg and the overarching objectives of Red Bull.

Leadership Characteristics and Responsibilities:

• Visionary Communication: According to Kotter (1996), transformational leaders excel at articulating a vision that motivates and inspires teams, fostering alignment and shared purpose.
• Adaptability: In volatile environments, leaders must remain flexible, adjusting strategies to changing circumstances (Bass, 1990).
• Cultural Integration: A leader must ensure that Salzburg’s unique culture is preserved while aligning with Red Bull’s global identity.

Appointing a charismatic and capable leader who embodies these traits will ensure that the team remains focused and resilient during organizational shifts. For example, Borussia Dortmund's successful rebuild in 2017-2019 was driven by hiring a strong coach who unified the team and re-established its identity (Shilbury & Ferkins, 2011).

2. Reinforce Team Identity

Team identity is the glue that binds players, coaches, and management, creating a sense of purpose and belonging. Investing in initiatives that strengthen this identity can improve cohesion and performance, especially in turbulent times.

Practical Strategies:

• Team-Building Exercises: Activities that encourage collaboration and trust can bridge gaps between players and staff, fostering a shared sense of mission (Katzenbach & Smith, 1993).
• Community Engagement: Strengthening ties with Salzburg’s local community enhances the team’s connection to its roots, creating a support system that bolsters morale during challenges.
• Cultural Reaffirmation: Highlighting Salzburg’s unique role within the Red Bull ecosystem, such as its commitment to youth development and competitive excellence, can reinforce pride and motivation among team members.

Case in Point: Leicester City’s resilience post-title win (2016-2018) demonstrates how emphasizing core values and community connections can reignite a team’s competitive edge.

3. Enhance Communication with Red Bull

Clear and consistent communication between RB Salzburg and Red Bull’s central leadership is essential for providing the team with the necessary resources and guidance. Communication gaps can lead to misalignment, resource inefficiencies, and a lack of strategic clarity.

Key Communication Initiatives:

• Regular Check-Ins: Establishing routine meetings between Salzburg’s management and Red Bull’s leadership ensures alignment on goals and resource needs (Mintzberg, 1983).
• Feedback Loops: Encouraging two-way communication allows Salzburg to share its on-the-ground challenges while benefiting from Red Bull’s strategic insights.
• Transparent Resource Allocation: Clearly defined support mechanisms, such as funding for infrastructure or staff, eliminate uncertainty and enable Salzburg to plan effectively.

Strong communication structures mirror effective organizational frameworks, as seen in successful multinational corporations that align regional units with global objectives (Foss & Pedersen, 2004).

4. Deepen Focus on Mental Fitness

Performance in high-pressure environments like professional football often depends as much on mental resilience as physical ability. Programs designed to enhance mental fitness can help players cope with uncertainty, reduce stress, and maintain focus.

Mental Fitness Programs:

• Sports Psychology Sessions: Addressing individual and team mental challenges fosters emotional stability and resilience (Gould et al., 1999).
• Mindfulness Training: Practices such as meditation and breathing exercises improve focus and reduce anxiety, which can enhance performance under pressure.
• Workshops on Coping Strategies: Sessions focused on managing change and uncertainty equip players to navigate organizational shifts without losing their competitive edge.

RB Salzburg’s struggles could benefit from lessons drawn from elite sports teams like Manchester City, which employs sports psychologists to optimize performance during critical moments.

5. Leverage Existing Infrastructure

RB Salzburg’s robust youth development program has been a cornerstone of its success, producing talented players who contribute to the team’s performance and identity. Leveraging this infrastructure ensures continuity and fosters hope for the future.

Strategies for Infrastructure Optimization:

• Talent Identification: Red Bull’s youth scouting network can be expanded to identify emerging talent early, ensuring a steady pipeline of skilled players.
• Player Development Programs: Enhanced training and mentorship opportunities for young players can prepare them to transition smoothly into the senior team.
• Community Integration: Involving youth players in community outreach initiatives strengthens their connection to Salzburg’s identity and values.

By prioritizing infrastructure and talent development, Salzburg can create a long-term strategy for sustainability, mirroring the success of its ice hockey counterparts in EC Red Bull Salzburg.

Conclusion

RB Salzburg’s recent struggles underscore the profound impact of leadership vacuums on team performance and organizational identity. While their physical training remains unchanged, the mental and cultural aspects of the team have been destabilized, resulting in declining performance. These lessons extend beyond football, offering insights for businesses managing smaller units within larger ecosystems.

By reinforcing leadership, investing in identity-building, and fostering autonomy within the broader corporate structure, RB Salzburg can regain their footing and emerge stronger. For Red Bull, the lessons learned here can guide how they manage other teams and divisions facing similar challenges in a time of organizational transition.

References

• Bass, B. M. (1990). From transactional to transformational leadership: Learning to share the vision. Organizational Dynamics, 18(3), 19-31.
• Eckel, C. C., & Grossman, P. J. (2005). Managing diversity by creating team identity. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 58(3), 371-392.
• Edmondson, A. C., & Lei, Z. (2014). Psychological safety: The history, renaissance, and future of an interpersonal construct. Annu. Rev. Organ. Psychol. Organ. Behav., 1(1), 23-43.
• Foss, N. J., & Pedersen, T. (2004). Organizing knowledge processes in the multinational corporation: An introduction. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(5), 340-349.
• Gould, D., Guinan, D., Greenleaf, C., & Chung, Y. (1999). The role of stress and the psychology of burnout in the performance of elite athletes. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 11(2), 200-218.
• Güpner, A., Seebacher, U. G., & Hillert, A. (2010). Corporate Mental Wellness:[mit Umsetzungsplan und Fallbeispielen]. USP Intern. Publ..
• Katzenbach, J. R., & Smith, D. K. (1993). The wisdom of teams: Creating the high-performance organization. Harvard Business Review Press.
• Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change. Harvard Business Review Press.
• Mintzberg, H. (1983). Structure in fives: Designing effective organizations. Prentice-Hall.
• Shilbury, D., & Ferkins, L. (2011). Professionalization, sport governance, and strategic capability. European Sport Management Quarterly, 11(5), 483-503. https://doi.org/10.1080/16184742.2011.624109